The fan disappointment and anger stemming from the Orioles trading Adley Rutschman is certainly understandable.
No matter how president of baseball operations Mike Elias tried to spin it Monday evening, he threw in the towel on what little hope remained for the 2026 season by trading his three-time All-Star catcher to the Boston Red Sox. That he also dealt outfielder Taylor Ward and pitchers Dean Kremer and Tyler Wells — the latter two carrying club control for next season — without adding any impact major-league talent before Monday’s trade deadline only reinforced that.
Of course, Rutschman’s exit is what cuts deep.
The former first overall pick was anointed the face of a multiyear rebuild in 2019 and was the symbol of hope for a fan base subjected to mostly lousy baseball with very few reprieves since the mid-1980s. That reality is something the present leadership of this franchise often fails to recognize, which is a problem much greater in scope than how the current team is performing on the field. Yes, the scars run deeper than those tanking seasons under Elias, which is why this short-circuited competitive window feels like a betrayal and a failure to keep a promise for so many.
From the moment Rutschman arrived in the majors on May 21, 2022, all appeared to be going to plan as the Orioles began winning only weeks later. The switch-hitting catcher was everything Baltimore imagined him to be over those first two-plus calendar years, which included the club’s first 100-win season in 43 years in 2023 and a strong first half of 2024 that led to back-to-back playoff appearances for the first time since 1996 and 1997.
But the idea of Rutschman and the player himself then began to diverge, which coincided with the two-year decline that’s brought the Orioles to this demoralizing point of Elias selling at the trade deadline for a second straight year and trading the onetime face of the franchise — to an AL East rival, no less. To say it’s difficult for many fans to stomach would be an understatement, especially in the wake of owner David Rubenstein recently saying he “couldn’t be more pleased” with the work Elias has done.
That work hasn’t included a single playoff win in eight seasons.
8
The truth is this iteration of the Orioles isn’t working and hasn’t been for quite some time. Citing the still-hopeful math in a lousy AL wild-card picture only does so much to deodorize a big picture looking increasingly disconcerting. That one can count the number of days Baltimore has been above .500 the last two seasons on two hands says plenty.
Part of that truth is Rutschman’s decline in performance and availability over the last two calendar years wasn’t an insignificant reason why the Orioles have fallen to this point. He was awful over the second half of 2024 and wasn’t particularly good last year either when a pair of oblique injuries accompanied still-disappointing production. And though Rutschman rebounded this season to earn his third trip to the All-Star game as the Orioles’ lone representative and was better than ever defensively, his overall numbers at the plate were buoyed by a monster April — he owns a .218/.309/.362 slash line since May 1 — and availability concerns persisted with three more trips to the injured list.
It’s not as though the Orioles were winning with Rutschman, going 101-125 with him in the lineup since July 1, 2024.
To be clear, there were certainly scenarios for a sensible contract extension of a few years, but one could just as easily make arguments against a lucrative long-term commitment for a catcher with mounting durability concerns scheduled to hit free agency ahead of his age-30 season in 2028. And if an extension wasn’t going to be in the cards, trading Rutschman now to maximize the return is certainly defensible. That’s especially true when considering the uncertainty created by the anticipated lockout this winter and how that could disrupt, shorten, or even wipe away next season.
But where do the Orioles go from here?
Though it would be way too dramatic to compare this sell-off to anything resembling the full-scale rebuild under Elias, trading players carrying club control next season and not adding any high-impact pieces for 2027 at the deadline — like Toronto did — spoke for itself. There are still too many position players underperforming with star shortstop Gunnar Henderson topping the list of disappointments and moving closer and closer to free agency himself.
Considering the way the much-hyped young position core has largely flopped or regressed, the roster construction has been so flawed, and the promise of a sustained competitive window hasn’t come to fruition, why should Elias be granted a mulligan of this magnitude to continue running the franchise?
8Why should fans be asked to continue trusting the man in charge of this disappointment?
No, the Orioles aren’t devoid of talent and have made long-term commitments to Samuel Basallo, Pete Alonso, starting pitchers Kyle Bradish and Shane Baz, and reliever Yennier Cano over the last calendar year, but the current club still looks closer in nature to some of the directionless teams over 14 straight years of losing from 1998-2011 than one truly building something special at this point. And while much of the baseball industry seems to believe Elias did well with the returns on his latest batch of trades, it would be difficult to project these acquisitions moving the needle in the next season or two.
In other words, if Elias and ownership believe they’re going to sell fans on the hope of shiny farm-system rankings in the midst of a continuing lull at the major-league level, good luck with that.
Ultimately, Monday’s frustration was about trading away what Rutschman represented more than the player he’d become in the midst of the Orioles disappointing for more than two years now.
Elias trading the face of the original rebuild was the loudest confirmation yet that this simply isn’t working.
